Bagel Boys Cafe Menu

Welcome to Bagel Boys Cafe, a gem nestled in Suffern, NY, where delightful flavors and freshness come together. Specializing in the best hand-rolled water bagels, their offerings start at just $1.99 for individual bagels and an impressive $21.99 for a dozen (with an extra bonus—15 for the price of 12!). Choose from an array of flavors, including classic favorites like everything and cinnamon raisin.

The cafe doesn't stop at bagels; it elevates your dining experience with delectable smoked fish sandwiches, featuring fresh baked salmon salad and Nova Scotia salmon paired with rich cream cheese. For those craving a hearty meal, the homemade salads are a must-try, with options like the Cobb Salad and Pan Asian Salad available.

Customers rave about the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, which makes dining in or grabbing a quick bite equally enjoyable. Don’t miss the pastries; they have a loyal following, too!